The Good, The Bad, The Ugly

By JD Lagrange – The Canadiens have reached the 14 games mark and force is to admit that they have surprised many pundits in the hockey world so far. That includes many of their fans, and members of their wolf-like media pack, who thought that the team would be falling in the bottom-five of the NHL once again.

The season is still young and it’s way too early to celebrate, it’s true. After all, the team was in a similar position at this point last season before everything started crumbling due to the countless injuries to key players. But so far – knock on wood – the team has only lost one player long term in Kirby Dach, who is done for the season after having knee surgery to repair not one, but two torn ligaments. David Savard is also out for 6-8 weeks with a fractured left hand.

The team improved depth has been paying dividends so far, and it’s particularly noticeable at the center position. While the Alex Newhook experiment at center hasn’t been conclusive, the return of Christian Dvorak has provided a boost to this line-up. Savard’s loss is more difficult to replace as neither Johnathan Kovacevic or Jordan Harris have been able to face the tougher opposition on the top-4 so far.

A few hours from puck drop against the Vancouver Canucks, the Canadiens are two games above .500 and sit fifth in the Atlantic Division. They are only one point back of the Florida Panthers, two back of Toronto and Detroit. The Canadiens have a game in hand on every one of those teams except on the Panthers. Further, the Habs have won back to back games against their division rivals Red Wings and Bruins.

Today, I’ve decided to highlight a few players so far and the cowboy in me picked a good old classic Western to make my point. Here are The Good, The Bad and The Ugly for the first 12 games.

The Good

A few players have really stood out so far this season and I’ve picked

  • Sean Monahan: what a start to the season for Mony! Third on the team in scoring with 12 points, and a faceoffs’ percentage of almost 60%.
  • Brendan Gallagher: Many had left him out for dead and finished, but Gally has bounced back so far this year. His five goals have him tied with Caufield, one back of Monahan and Suzuki.
  • Cole Caufield: Mr. Overtime already has three OT goals so far. What’s more surprising from Cole so far is his playmaking abilities, with 14 points in as many games.
  • Nick Suzuki: They were many to criticize the Canadiens’ captain earlier this season but that proved to be a futile exercise, as he’s once again leading the team in goals (6) and second in points (13).
  • Kaiden Guhle: The young defenseman missed four games to injuries so far but he’s been a rock defensively. Only Matheson has more points than Guhle amongst the team’s defensemen, and he leads the Canadiens with a surprising +9 rating.
  • Justin Barron: In spite of the fact that I had written about the possibility of him surprising, Barron is a transformed player. In fact, I’d go as far as saying that he’s the most stable defenseman on the right side for the Habs so far this season.

The Bad

Others have been up and down. In this case, the term “bad” might be a bit severe, I’ll be the first to admit. But these guys, in my opinion, can and should offer more.

  • Mike Matheson: His situation is weird. At times, he’s like Bobby Orr and other times, he’s Jeff Petry. More consistency should be expected from Matheson but he’s still, with Guhle and Barron, the Canadiens’ best defenseman.
  • Alex Newhook: Prior to Dach’s injury, Newhook started on fire. But since being moved to center, he struggled mightily. He creates stuff with his speed, but there’s something missing in his game.
  • Sam Montembeault: The starter position was his for the taking, but he’s been outplayed this season by Jake Allen. Up, down, up, down. Stats are okay, but the bad goals are a killer. Elliotte Friedman claims that the Canadiens and Monty are close in a contract extension.
  • Johnathan Kovacevic: He’s better suited for the third pair and penalty kills. When asked to play on the top-4, like he’s had to do with Savard’s injury, he struggles. Not his fault, it’s not his chair. He’s not meant to play consistently against top opposition.

The Ugly

Some stand out in the eyes of fans and media, but for the wrong reasons. Their production is not where it should be, for whatever reasons.

  • Josh Anderson: It hurts me to put him here but the stats line is just not good enough to bring him higher. He’s holding the stick tight but at least, he’s creating offensive opportunities for the team. If he can get one, the monkey will be off his back.
  • Juraj Slafkovsky: Much like for Anderson, it hurts me to put Slaf here. This is NOT a knock against the kid, whom I wanted the Habs to pick. He is progressing, but the offensive output is simply not there. And for a first overall pick, some offense should be expected. Like Andy, he has been getting some chances.
  • Jordan Harris: One has to be quite critical to put Harris on this list but he hasn’t been the shadow of himself so far this season. He’s being outmuscled and makes questionable decisions from time to time in his zone. His passes are not as crisp as they were last season. Playing on his wrong side isn’t helping any…
  • Joel Armia: He got a kick in the pants when sent to Laval, where his attitude was irreproachable and his production was great. He had a couple of good games after being called back up but he has disappeared since. He just doesn’t have it.

There you have it folks. Admittedly, I’m anticipating a lot of pushback on some of those. It’s all a matter of opinion, of course, and my list certainly isn’t the Bible of assessments. It’s simply based on what I, personally, was expecting from some of the Canadiens’ players. But rest assured that this is not meant as a player-bashing article. In fact, in spite of the struggles by some of the players listed above, the start of the season is, overall, quite positive.

Monahan Re-Signs: His Impact

By JD Lagrange – The Montreal Canadiens have announced having re-signed veteran center and pending UFA Sean Monahan for one year, worth $1.985 million. Monahan also has a $15,000 bonus based on the number of games that he plays, potentially bringing his salary up to the $2 million mark.

I don’t know what this mean for the possibility of the Canadiens acquiring Pierre-Luc Dubois but personally, I saw Monahan as a “plan B” in the event a Dubois trade was not possible. I am still holding hopes that a trade with the Jets can be done, perhaps with Christian Dvorak being sent the other both for salary reason, and because he is a center. But we shall know more in the coming days, as we are only eight days away from the NHL Draft as I write this.

Monahan’s impact

There is no denying that Sean Monahan had a very positive impact both on the Canadiens as a team, but also on some of the individual players as well, in particular on young captain Nick Suzuki. Mony has always been very much respected in Calgary and many former teammates were upset to see him go, and he embraced the City of Montreal and the logo from day one.

Here is the Canadiens’ record with and without Monahan in the line-up.

Team record
With MonahanWithout Monahan
.520 (21st)PTS%.368 (29th)
2.92 (22nd)GF/GP2.70 (29th)
3.60 (27th)GA/GP3.77 (29th)
17.1% (29th)PP%15.6% (28th)
79.1% (12th)PK%69.8% (32nd)
51.6% (12th)FO%47.1% (27th)

Granted, with all of the injuries to other players than Monahan himself, it’s unlikely that the team would have kept on its pace of early into the season, up until December 5th, his last game. But it shows the impact that he had on the games in all situations, whether it’d be at even strength, on the power play or in short handed situations.


Few have suffered more from Monahan’s injury than Suzuki. Monahan ate some key minutes and provided quality experience, allowing Zukes to focus more on offense. After the injury, the captain played well over 20 minutes a game, in all situations, and wasn’t quite as effective overall.

With MonahanSUZUKIWithout Monahan
Other players

Monahan’s impact went well beyond Suzuki. With such a young team, he was a quality veteran with great leadership attributes, added to the other leaders the team already had. And his on ice production in all situations was a contributing factor to the Canadiens’ surprising start to the season, after finishing dead last the previous season.

This were the Habs Top-10 scorers with Monahan in the line-up, prior to him going on the injured reserve:

1- Nick Suzuki25141428-11.12
2- Cole Caufield2514923-40.92
3- Kirby Dach2541418-20.72
4- Sean Monahan2561117-50.68
5- Christian Dvorak255510-10.40
6- Kaiden Guhle251910-80.40
7- Josh Anderson23628-20.35
8- Mike Hoffman16538+30.50
9- Arber Xhekaj2344800.35
10- Brendan Gallagher22358-30.36

Now let’s look at the Habs Top-10 scorers without Monahan in the line-up:

1- Nick Suzuki57122638-120.67
2- Mike Matheson4072229+110.73
3- Mike Hoffman5191726-130.51
4- Jonathan Drouin4622325-140.54
5- Josh Anderson4615924-60.52
6- Rafaël Harvey-Pinard3414620+70.59
7- Kirby Dach3310102000.61
8- Christian Dvorak3951318-110.46
9- Jesse Ylönen3761016-110.43
10- Jake Evans2921416+30.55
16- Cole Caufield2112113-60.62

Looking at all of this, it is safe to affirm that having Monahan back with the Canadiens is a good thing. But it’s only one small step for Kent Hughes and the management staff, as there are bigger issues to deal with.

Will the Hughes be able to pull another rabbit out of his hat, as he did a year ago when acquiring Kirby Dach? Will Dubois end up in Montreal? Maybe so, or maybe not. Will the GM want to improve his goaltending situation? Let’s hope so as unlike many fans, I’m not sold on Sam Montembeault as a starter in the NHL. Does Hughes still feel like adding a veteran top-paire right-handed defenseman is a priority? Too many questions, too few answers. In the meantime, the rumour mill will be going strong. We will know more by June 28th, the first day of the NHL Draft.