Habs and Hawks Could Be Good Trade Partners

It’s been an off-season to forget for both the Montreal Canadiens and the Chicago Blackhawks. In Montreal, it’s been controversy over shocking news ever since the team has lost in the Stanley Cup Finals. Losing their captain Shea Weber, the departure of Joel Bouchard, Carey Price left unprotected for the Expansion Draft, the selection of Logan Mailloux, Phillip Danault leaving, Paul Byron having surgery, Jesperi Kotkaniemi gone with an offer-sheet, Price going on the players assistance program…

For the Hawks, the question marks about captain Jonathan Toews’ health situation, the trade of Duncan Keith, the trade for Marc-Andre Fleury and his subsequent silence for several days, and this whole story about Brad Aldrich and the fall outs since the investigation report came out, including the resignation of GM Stan Bowman. Results? Both teams are mightily struggling out of the gate this season. Both teams need a shake up and start focussing on the season as they are falling fast in the standings.

Please note that I have no sources either with the Canadiens or the Blackhawks and this is only a suggestion that I, personally, feel might work for both teams. I’m not going to venture (too much) into the exact details of a potential deal between the two teams but I do feel like they can help each other out. Add or remove a piece here and there, customize it to your liking. So take the following with a grain of salt… a slice of lime and a shot of tequila!

Trade idea

Here’s what could be the foundation for a potential substantial trade between Montreal and Chicago.

To Montreal:

  • Connor Murphy (RD): carries a $3.85 million cap hit this season, then $4.4 million for four more years after.
  • Dylan Strome (C): $3 million cap hit this season, RFA in the summer with arbitration rights.
  • Andrew Shaw (C/RW): on LTIR for the entire season, $3.9 million LTIR cap.

To Chicago:

  • Ryan Poehling (C): $750,000 cap hit for two years, then RFA.
  • An “A” level prospect or the Habs’ 2nd round pick.
  • One of Artturi Lehkonen, Joel Armia or Paul Byron: for cap relief.
  • “B” level prospects to unload a contract as the Habs are at 48 contracts (max of 50) prior to this trade.

The Habs desperately need a right-handed defenseman who can help Jeff Petry on the right side facing the opposition’s top lines. Petry has been struggling big time so far this season and he’s not the shadow of his old self. Murphy stands at 6-foot 4-inches and weights 212 lbs and he skates very well for such a big man. The 28 year-old has a pretty good shot and usually makes good first passes out of his zone. While he’ll never be in consideration for the Norris Trophy, he goes about his business in a steady and efficient fashion. Good defender, he can be a bit inconsistent as a shut down. He’s a huge improvement over David Savard in just about every aspect.

Strome is a centre who stands at 6-foot 3-inches and 200 lbs. The 24 year-old has only played two games thus far this season and he’s in the coach’s bad books due to his inconsistency. The expectations were high on this former third overall pick by Arizona back at the 2015 NHL Draft but his production has dipped in the past couple of seasons. Habs Rumour Mill informed us that the Habs were scouting the Hawks not long ago and, coincidently, Strome was inserted into the line-up for that game.

The Canadiens still hold 11 picks for the 2022 NHL Draft and are loaded on quality prospects, particularly on left-hand shot defensemen.

Laval/Montreal swap

Last but not least, I personally would send young Cole Caufield down to Laval for a while if, for nothing else, regain his confidence. We’ve never heard anyone say that a player stayed too long in the AHL before making the jump to the NHL but how many times have we seen players being rushed to the NHL, often in roles too big, too soon? The Habs cannot afford to mess the development of this kid as they have done with too many young players in recent history.

The call-up? None other than Michael Pezzetta, who in my humble opinion and based on merit, should have never been sent down to Laval in the first place. He’s on fire with the Rocket. Ducharme could easily bump up Joel Armia (or Lehkonen) to the top-9 forwards and play Pezzetta on the fourth line.

I fully anticipate to read many people, from both or either sides (Habs and/or Hawks) being totally against this idea. And that’s okay, I respect that. Remember that there are few trades happening because few GMs can agree on the value of players so imagine how unrealistic it would be to expect fans agreeing. This is a move that I would like, or something along those lines. It’s far from meaning that it would happen in real life. But it’s still fun to speculate. It beats complaining day in, day out, or arguing with other fans, doesn’t it?

3 thoughts on “Habs and Hawks Could Be Good Trade Partners

  1. Don’t see why Hawks would do this, seems massive under payment.
    Poehling can’t even crack weak centre depth on Habs, now has major history of injuries to boot. Has yet to show he can be an NHL player.
    Strome has shown that and just last season was putting up over half point/game and playing with Panarin/PP. Murphy is obv a legit player, in his prime for defence man and trending upwards.
    Habs would have to give up one of the forward listed (think Lehkonen is most likely, Byro too old/injuries, Armia older than Lehks) plus a young NHL player (all Habs stock is low) but it would likely have to be Romanov, maybe Kulak + a couple second round picks gets it done too. Habs have too many LHD with Eddy coming back soon. Romanov is going to be back fighting for third pair minutes again, With Kulak, Niku and even Wideman. May be time to move him, especially if plans are to resign Chiarot.
    Murphy is way too good, for reasons you mentioned. Hawks have a lot of young players in minors, amateur levels so will be hard to sell them on that type of player, they will be wanting NHL’ers back. No idea how these contracts balance, but both team have lots of LTIR to manipulate.

Comments are closed.